Virginia: Medical Malpractice – a Lawyer’s Pleading

Virginia: Medical Malpractice – a Lawyer’s Pleading

Marshall v. Moniz is a medical malpractice lawsuit pending in Circuit Court for York County, Virginia. Defendants have filed a Demurrer to strike Plaintiff’s “catch-all” allegation of negligence: “Such other tortious acts and omissions as may be investigated, discovered and proved”.

Yet, it is hornbook law that Virginia is a “notice” pleading state. “Every pleading shall state facts on which the party relied in numbered paragraphs, and it shall be sufficient if it clearly informs the opposite party of the true nature of the claim or defense.” Va. Sup. Ct. Rule 1:4(d)(emphasis added).

Conversely, Virginia pleading does not require plaintiffs to itemize details of negligence. “An allegation of negligence. . . is sufficient without specifying the particulars of the negligence.” Va. Sup. Ct. Rule 3:18(b)(emphasis added).

A Demurrer is used to make “the contention that a pleading does not state a cause of action or that such pleading fails to state facts upon which the relief demanded can be granted.” Va. Code Ann. §8.01-273(A). “[I]t is unnecessary for the pleader to descend into statements giving the details of the proof in order to withstand demurrer” if the complaint informs the defendant of the nature and character of the claim. Catercorp, Inc. v. Cathering Concepts, Inc., 246 Va. 22, 24 (1993).

Thus, in Ragsdale v. Jones, 202 Va. 278, 284 (1960), the Virginia Supreme Court upheld the admission of intoxication evidence, even through negligence in general and not intoxication in particular was pleaded. Likewise, in Moore v. Jefferson Hosp., Inc., 208 Va. 438, 439 (1967)(reversing a supposed failure to state), the Virginia Supreme Court found sufficient plaintiff’s pleading of negligence that defendant “proximately caused injury to the plaintiff, both mental and physical”. Likewise, Moore v. Payless Supermarket, Inc., 18 Va. Cir. 197, 200 ( Wise Sep. 15, 1989) found the “general allegation of negligence is sufficient”. Similarly, Cunningham v. Roanoke Reg. Airport Comm’n, 70 Va. Cir. 273, 276 ( Roanoke Mar. 8, 2006) held “pleadings are not required to assert anything more than a general allegation of negligence”.